RSS
Share

1989 Chateau Montrose Vs 1990 Montrose Who’s on First?

pin it button 1989 Chateau Montrose Vs 1990 Montrose Whos on First?

1990 Montrose 300x244 1989 Chateau Montrose Vs 1990 Montrose Whos on First?

Since the day this Bordeaux wine was released, I have always felt 1989 Montrose the better wine of the dynamic duo.  21 years after the 1990 Montrose was made, my view has suddenly changed.
1990 Chateau Montrose remains a deep ruby color. An intoxicating perfume of smoked meat, tobacco, blackberry, barnyard, gritty earth, spice and cassis pops from the wine as it spills into your glass.  This wine is powerful, dense and masculine, as well as refined. There are no hard edges to be found. Layers of flavor float all over your palate, teeth and gums.  This stunning wine ends with a long, pure, clean cassis, blackberry and spice sensation that seems to last for close to 50 seconds. The wine continued improving in the glass for several hours.
The problem with this wine has been the massive wall of tannin and amount of brett many bottles have displayed. This example was a very clean wine. As you can see from my comments, the tannins have integrated into this St. Estephe wine.
While secondary aromas are clearly developed, this is only now starting to become civilized. As good as this bottle is today, it will be better with 10-20 or even 30 more years of bottle age.  99 Pts
.
1989  Chateau Montrose –  Tobacco, truffle, cassis, wet earth and BBQ aromas reveal themselves without much effort.  Full bodied, dense and filled with blackberry, cassis and earthy flavors, this mouth filling wine coats your palate with layers of rich, ripe, roasted, spicy black fruit. Tobacco, truffle, cassis, wet earth and BBQ aromas reveal themselves without much effort.  This Medoc wine is full bodied, dense and filled with blackberry, cassis and earthy flavors, this mouth filling wine coats your palate with layers of rich, ripe, roasted, spicy black fruit. Still young and fresh, this beautiful example of Montrose that perfectly pairs power with elegance will evolve for decades.   97 Pts

Comments

  1. Blake Layne says:

    Awesome to hear. I have one bottle that I can’t bring myself to open. Looks like it is going to keep sleeping!

  2. Blake… If you only have one bottle of 90 Montrose, you should give it another 10-20 years. Other posters have weighed in the 89 or Montrose debate here … http://thewinecellarinsider.com/forums_new/showthread.php?217-1989-Montrose-Vs-1990-Montrose…-Which-Bordeaux-wine-came-out-on-top

  3. Montrose 1990 :
    92/100 (Montrose verticale – december 2007) – wait
    94/100 (september 2004, served along with an excellent Valandraud 1994) – wait

    Montrose 1989 :
    94/100 (Montrose verticale – december 2007) – wait

    Full report with pics : http://invinoveritastoulouse.fr/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=77:20071220-montrose-verticale-en-39-millesimes&catid=46:thematique-domaine&Itemid=58